What would you do if your aging parent got a diagnosis of cancer before tests confirmed it?
In this post, I share a horrifying experience that my mother had yesterday. I share it because I want to raise awareness of what a seemingly respected medical director of a retirement community chose to do. I also want to share how I responded to my mother, the doctor and reflect how we, as adult children, can be the best possible advocate for our parents.
After 5 years of relatively good health and quality of life, my 80 year old mother went to her doctor Friday afternoon for a follow-up visit of some blood work and tests to identify the cause of her anemia. (She is in Maryland, this doctor has been her primary care doctor for many years, she visits him every 3 months, and he is the medical director of her continuing care retirement community.) The doc shared her test results, and proceeded to tell my mother that she could very well have colon cancer and by now, it could have spread throughout her body. Was my mother shocked and confused? Yes, because she had not yet had her colonscopy (her first ever!) and the diagnosis suddenly went from anemia to the big C, cancer!!!
Mom immediately called me at work to share what the doctor said. She was in a total state of shock in her apartment alone in Maryland on a Friday afternoon. I was in Indiana and my brother, in Virginia, was out of town. I asked Mom to call both her doctors and give me permission to speak with them.
I then took about 30 minutes to compose myself. Facts, emotions, scenarios were swirling in my mind. I knew I had take action (and the right action) because there were only 2 hours left to Friday afternoon! Here’s what happened next!
Mom’s wellness center called to let me know her doc would be calling me. In the meantime, I called her auto-immune specialist at Johns Hopkins to let him know the situation and as much of her diagnosis as possible. Interesting that he cut her doses of prednisone and imuran a few months back. (As a sidenote, Mom’s primary doc had responded to her that he saw no need to share her current health situation with her specialist.) I talked with the specialist’s nurse, gave her as much info as I had, and indicated I would call back in a week, to ensure all tests results were sent by primary doc.
And, then, my mom’s primary care doc called me. I know this is a long post, but please hang in there and read the rest…..I hope it may help you and your parent someday.
The doc had no idea of the impact his words had on mom.
- I began by having him repeat everything he told mom. When he stopped, I said, “and tell me what else you said to her.”
- He told me he didn’t want to withhold information from patients and thus, proceeded to present possible scenarios (of Cancer!) so she could start to absorb the shock of it. I asked, do you have clear evidence of cancer? He responded no. I let that comment sit.
- I moved on and told him that Mom sensed he lacked compassion from his manner. There was total silence again. Then the rationalization began. He said since she showed no emotion, he took that to mean that she was accepting what he said “matter of factly”. I told him that she shared with me that was not the case. She was in total shock!
- One of the worse parts for Mom was when Mom sensed he was appalled that she wanted to aggressively treat whatever the problem was. He indicated this to me as well. I told him that was a resident/patient’s prerogative to choose!!! Mom said it seemed to her that he felt like her life didn’t matter anymore.
So, how did all this end (for now)? I told the doc I wanted to be conference-called in on all her appointments and he agreed. I also told him I had contacted her specialist, and I wanted him to share all the test results with him,,,,,and to partner with him. He agreed. And, he offered to call my mother back and have a conversation, which he did. My mother said he sounded as if he was just trying to cover himself. And, thus we are also considering changing docs after the rest of the test results come in.
So, until Mom has her colonoscopy, there is no evidence of cancer. Of course, we all hope it’s not cancer. My dear sweet mother finished our conversation by asking, “if there is bad news, can we have my birthday party earlier?” I said, “of course.”
As advocates for our parents, we have to be vigilant and find a way to walk that fine line with physicians so we don’t alienate them but have them clearly listen, understand and partner with us on behalf of our parents.



{ 9 comments… read them below or add one }
I am very sorry for what your mother went through that was totally disgusting and uncalled for. how horrible to have to sit and wait and wonder and wait all the time for the test and results
This is part of what Obama care is teaching and instructing doctors to Do by telling the elderly to go take a pill and lay down. because if it is cancer and because of her age doctors may not be allowed to give reatment. We need to stop how the Obamacare is going to affect our parents
Prayers for you and your mom
I am truly sorry for you and your Mother. Being close to your Mother’s age I can well imagine what a shock this was to you and her. I will share this with my children.
Thanks for alerting us.
Winifred
My mother said the doc scheduled her colonoscopy for Feb 8th. 3 weeks out. Reminds me of something my doctor’s nurse said at my last annual exam. She advised me to continue working full-time for as long as I can to delay going on Medicare!
I am so sorry for the problem. I love Jean and do hope this is resolved in her favor.
You are such a good daughter for taking care of your mom. I know you love her and you will be blessed for your caring and compassion. Both you and Jean are in my prayers.
Your friend of 20 years.
Much love,
Cathy
Dale-so sorry to hear about this terrible, scary, life halting experience with your mom’s doctor. Unfortunately, my sister had a very similar experience from a medical staff member (the doctor’s nurse told her a abnormal scan may mean cancer, or nothing at all….really? why go there! And on a Friday afternoon just like your experience!). I think that there are many factors that may be causing this lack of tack when it comes to serious medical news. I don’t know if it is due to the high amount of patients that doctors are now seeing, if it is a basic lack of respect for someone’s ability to cope, or if it is fear of lawsuits and wanting to disclose any possibility even if it is the most remote. During the visits where I accompany my clients, I am seeing more and more doctors who are pushed to rush through appointments, and the attention and care is no longer there. But I have also met with several doctors that are sensitive to their patient’s needs and are aware that some news needs to be shared cautiously. Another factor is that most medical practices deal with life changing illness on a daily basis. Maybe they are desensitized to the impact it has on people especially those who do not have supports. Regardless of why, the human factor of care is sometimes not a strong concern for medical providers. It isn’t something that can be regulated or forced-either you have insight into how people are going to react and care about how they deal with things and act appropriately, or you don’t. Bravo for calling this doctor out on his inappropriate choice of words with your mom. Although it is horrible that your family had to go through this, I hope that this doctor will think twice before doing this again.
Dale,
I finally had a minute to read this. I do not care for doctors in general, and hearing your mom’s story did not help. My 88 year old dad, already diagnosed with Dementia, went to the hospital and was given a lung cancer diagnosis with 2 months to live…. It is past the 2 month mark and he is gaining weight, taking a few steps, has round the clock care, but no more symptoms. Our health care practitioners appear to be operating in a vacuum. They are not God. The caregivers; however; act like angels. Good for you Daughter Caregiver. You are in the right place, making a huge impact and your mom is lucky to have you advocating, even from a distance. Sending thoughts and prayers.
Unfortunately this is not an isolated case. I had a situation with my mother on a different level than the big ‘C’ but nevertheless it seemed the doctor only thought in a silo and did not seem to have the empathy needed. If doctors would only think before they speak and consider how they might handle things if it were ‘their own loved one” it could help. Thankfully your mother has a wonderful daughter who took this doctor to task. Many of us just give in and do whatever the doctor says without considering that they are human too and can make mistakes. Congratulations to you for bringing this awareness to us all.
gee, this is a sign my mom is 85 also on march 29 they did a ct scan and said my mom had the c word in the cecum of the colon and the nurse at hospital ltold her she had 6 months she has not been the same, the oncology dr who is great told mom that a colonscopy is eally unnecessary and she has never gotten one in her life but I felt like it should be done, but as I speak my mom is as the say transitioning I just hate to give up hope somedays she is very tired and other days she is ok we get her hair done and so its so very hard. I also reported that nurse and even the dr told me no one should ever say this no one knows how long and so I felt ok but my mom still hears her saying this, do you think I should put my mom through this I feel like we are giving up.
Joann,
I so empathize with what you and your mom are going through. A year ago a physician I interviewed told me, “age is just a number. Do not ever make a decision based solely on chronological age.” My mom, age 80, decided to “fight it”. And, I will tell you, she came through the surgery and 21 days of rehab remarkably. Even though painful to recover (a very large incision and removal of part of bowel), by the time she left rehab, she said she felt better than she had in years!
We had our challenges along the way… The surgeon told her before hospital discharge that she had stage 4….that had to be our lowest point. But, after a PET scan and blood work, the oncologist said she was stage 3. Mom decided to go ahead and take oral chemo for the advised 6 months. She is in month 2, and her only complaint is fatigue. Her appetite has returned and with the help of Boost, she has been able to stabilize her weight.
I must admit, I was initially the doubter, wanting my mother to have quality of life, not some painful surgery….but my mother seems renewed by getting rid of the cancerous mass and living her life on her terms. BTW, my mother told me her colonoscopy (and the prep) was no big deal.
I hope this our experience helps you and your mother as you weigh the alternatives. If you have any more questions, I’ll be glad to answer you privately. Just submit another comment and I will answer privately.